Auction Detail
January 2023
Our January 2023 sales include the "Erivan" Collection of United and Confederate States Postal History Part VIII, as well as a general sale of United States and worldwide stamps, covers, and collections.
- (-) Remove United States of America filter United States of America
- (-) Remove Confederate States of America filter Confederate States of America
- Confederate States 1861 3c Postmasters’ Provisionals (1) Apply Confederate States 1861 3c Postmasters’ Provisionals filter
- Confederate States Postmasters’ Provisionals (21) Apply Confederate States Postmasters’ Provisionals filter
- Confederate States General Issues (11) Apply Confederate States General Issues filter
- (-) Remove Confederate States of America filter Confederate States of America
stamp tied by "Hillsboro N.C. May 27 1861" double circle datestamp to cover to "Priestly H. Magnum, Raleigh, No. Ca.", cover expertly restored and repaired with pencil notations on the front erased, very fine appearance, one of two Hillsboro provisionals known and the unique example used at the 3c United States letter rate, 2022 Civil War Philatelic Society certificate (Scott listed but unpriced)
This cover was first described in a 1984 article by Patricia A. Kaufmann describing the 1861 United States 3c Postmaster Provisionals used in the Confederacy (Confederate Philatelist Vol. 29, No. 5). Although the Confederacy was formed on February 4, 1861, the act prescribing the rates of postage in the CSA did not go into effect until June 1. As Kaufmann explains:
"Postmasters from seceded states which joined the Confederacy found themselves in a very difficult position. While most postmasters were sympathetic to the South and intended subsequently to accept Confederate postmaster commissions, they still were technically under oath to the United States Post Office Department until June 1, 1861. The United States demanded a confirming oath from these southern postmasters be fore they would ship additional supplies of U.S. stamps to them during the period between the formation of the Confederacy and June 1, 1861."
This unique set of circumstances led to the issuance of postage stamps by a small number of Confederate postmasters during this brief window in early 1861. While a Hillsboro 5c provisional (used June 7, under the newly-established Confederate postal service) has been recognized for some time (at least since the 1929 edition of Dietz's book), the cover offered here was not described until Kaufmann's article.
May 27, 1861, the date of this cover, coincides with the date that North Carolina joined the Confederacy (after seceding from the United States a week prior). It was also the date that United States Postmaster General Montgomery Blair ordered the discontinuance of US mail through the seceded states except West Virginia. Both the Richmond Daily Dispatch and Macon Daily Telegraph announced that the Confederate Post Office Department would not be able to furnish new stamps for some time, which (combined with the patriotic fervor of being the newest state in the Confederacy) almost certainly led to the creation of this provisional stamp.
perfect strike of provisional handstamp at upper left of cover to Dawson, Georgia, matching "Albany Ga Feb 8 1862" datestamp at right, extremely fine strikes and cover (Scott $1,000)
Provenance: John R. Hill, Jr. (Private transaction)
full margins including sheet margin at top and right, tied by black "Baton Rouge La Dec 18" datestamp to cover to Donaldsville, Louisiana, cover with vertical and horizontal creases away from stamp, very fine and attractive, 2022 Civil War Philatelic Society certificate (Scott $5,000)
Provenance: Alfred H. Caspary (H.R. Harmer Sale 989, 1956)
Alexander S. Kirkman (H.R. Harmer Sale 1423, 1962)
black handstamp "Paid" with manuscript "5cts" and "J.T. Hall", matching "Demopolis Ala Nov 27" datestamp at top right, addressed to "Hon Moses McGuire, Probate Judge, Tuskaloosa", very fine, the unique Demopolis provisional with manuscript rate and the earliest recorded provisional envelope from Demopolis (Scott lists the three varieties out of chronological order), illustrated by M. Clinton McGee in his 1960 Confederate Philatelist article (Vol. 5, No. 11) which explains the discovery and history of these rare envelopes (Scott $4,000)
double-circle provisional handstamp at top right with matching "Gainsville Ala. Jan 2" datestamp at left on 1862 cover to Lauderdale Station, Mississippi, extremely fine and fresh, one of just seven examples of this envelope recorded in the Crown census (Scott $4,500)
Provenance: Alexander Hall (R.A. Siegel Sale 795, 1997)
four large margins, light cancel, couple trivial thins, extremely fine appearance, one of the most attractive of the few recorded examples of this stamp (Scott $12,000)
Provenance: Alfred H. Caspary (H.R. Harmer Sale 989, 1956)
(Alexander S. Kirkman Sale 1423, 1962)
essentially four margins with portion of adjacent stamp at right, tied by black "Paid" handstamp to folded letter (blue lined paper), additional red pen cancel, endorsed "O.B." and addressed to Captain William Headen in Corpus Christi, Texas, contents dated August 18, 1864, very fine, by far the finer of the two examples of the 10c "Goilad" error on cover and in our opinion one of the most desirable items of Confederate States postal history (Scott $30,000)
Provenance: Alfred H. Caspary (H.R. Harmer Sale 989, 1956)
Josiah K. Lilly (R.A. Siegel Sale 317, 1967)
on rebacked cover front, large margins, magenta pen cancel, affixed over blue "Paid 5" marking, "Grove Hill Ala Sep 10" datestamp alongside, addressed to Jackson, Alabama, cover front stained and faulty but stamp very fine and attractive, one of two recorded examples of the Grove Hill provisional, the other of which was one of the highlights of the first sale of the "Erivan" Collection in June 2019 and realized $110,000 hammer, 2022 Civil War Philatelic Society certificate (Scott $125,000)
Provenance: Alfred H. Caspary (H.R. Harmer Sale 989, 1956)
Josiah K. Lilly (R.A. Siegel Sale 317, 1967)
bold impression of provisional handstamp at upper right of cover addressed to Floyd Springs, Georgia, matching "Kingston Ga Jun 19" datestamp alongside, small piece added at top left away from handstamps, very fine strikes and cover, one of just three recorded examples of the Type II Kingston provisional in the Crown census (Scott $3,250)
Provenance: Harold C. Brooks (Laurence & Stryker Sale 123, 1943)
John R. Hill, Jr. (Private transaction)
single with rectangular margins, uncanceled on cover to Miss Lucy E. Simpson at Laurens Courthouse, South Carolina, address in the hand of Lizzie Dean as are all known covers with this stamp, expertly cleaned, extremely fine, one of just six recorded Limestone Springs provisional covers and the only example with a single rectangular stamp, a great rarity of Confederate States postal history, 2022 Civil War Philatelic Society certificate (Scott $10,000)
Provenance: A. Earl Weatherly (R.A. Siegel Sale 420, 1972)
Rarities of the World (R.A. Siegel Sale 824, 2000)
Dr. Karl Agre (R.A. Siegel Sale 850, 2002)
full margins at right and bottom, close at other two sides (owing to tight spacing on the plate), tied by "Lynchburg Va. Oct 30" datestamp to folded lettersheet to Curdsville, Virginia, very fine and fresh, the Crown census records 28 covers with single Lynchburg provisionals (Scott $4,000)
Provenance: Sidney A. Hessel (H.R. Harmer Sale 2291, 1975)
margins huge to clear with sheet margin at top, tied by "Macon Geo. Paid 5" handstamp (Scott type E1) to cover to Thomasville, Georgia, repaired backflap, very fine, the Crown census records 18 covers with the large 5c Macon provisional with a period after "Office", 2022 Civil War Philatelic Society certificate (Scott $6,000)
Provenance: Alfred H. Caspary (H.R. Harmer Sale 990, 1956)
H. Gray Muzzy (H.R. Harmer Sale 1764, 1967)